Pushkinskaya st. 43. office 10
Rostov-on-Don, Russia
344082
e-mail: info@hjournal.ru 
tel. +7(863) 269-88-14

cubsEN (2)

Doctrine of "Fair Price” by Thomas Aquinas: background, laws of development and specific interpretation

DOCTRINE OF "FAIR PRICE” BY THOMAS AQUINAS: BACKGROUND, LAWS OF DEVELOPMENT AND SPECIFIC INTERPRETATION

Journal of Institutional studies, , Vol. 7 (no. 1),

The paper is dedicated premises of origin and patterns of development of the doctrine of “fair price” Aquinas. Showing contradictions exchange of agricultural products to urban goods and services, resulting in a developed feudalism. For agricultural products incoming to the city market, the situation was characterized as the free competition, while medieval guild tried to create a monopoly conditions for the production and sale of its products, which objectively leads to distortion of prices. Under these conditions, the development of the problem of "fair price" becomes extremely important. The paper shows how scholasticism using theological methodology, trying to solve this problem.

Greed condemned, was considered evil and sin of avarice considered the source of all evils. This tradition goes back to the interpretation of the Gospel of Matthew John Chrysostom. Alexander Halensis one of the first attempted rehabilitation of commercial activities and even tried to criticize the position of the Pseudo-Chrysostom that the merchant is not pleasing to God. In the "sum of all theology" Alexander Halensis wrote that moral qualities profits depend on the circumstances of 6:

1. From the person selling (which allowed the laity, the monks are not allowed);

2. His intentions (satisfaction or desire for profit);

3. The method of sale (by fair means or fraud);

4. Time of trade (on weekdays or holidays, designed for prayer or service of God);

5. Selling place (in the market or in holy places);

6. Relationship to the buyers (which is expressed in the level - excessive or normal - the selling price).

Analyzes the rationale arguments to grounding the doctrine of "fair price", show the evolution of the concept during XII - XIV centuries, as well as its relationship with the teachings of the scholastics on the percentage. The paper deals with various estimates of the concept of "fair value" of Thomas Aquinas, resulting in the history of economic thought. Critically analyzed the "contribution" of Thomas Aquinas in the development of the labor theory of value. Such an ambiguous approach to a "fair" price led to what some researchers considered the forerunner of Thomas Aquinas, the cost of labor history: I. M. Kulisher (1906), R. H. Tawney (1926), J.-B. Kraus (1930), S. Hagenauer (1931), A. Fanfani (1935), O.V. Trachtenberg (1957), Y. Mike. (1994) - and others have tried to try on his views with utility theory (since it appeared demand Aquinas had to implement trade) trying to try two beginnings consumer and labor: H. Contzen (1869), E. Schreiber (1913), O. Scbilling (1923), R. De Roover (1958), R. M. Nureev (2005). Therefore, in the second half of the XX century, many researchers refuse to consider a "fair price" as the basis of cost, and steel is identified with its current market price: A. Sapori (1955), J. T. Noonan (1957), L. W. Baldwin (1959), Dr. T. Stetsyura (2010). The paper analyzes the arguments "pro" and "contra" in favor of each of these approaches.


Keywords: the medieval city; guild system; merchant and usury capital; feudal economic mentality; Trading profit «Fair price», scholasticism; Thomas Aquinas; the doctrine of the percentage

References:
  • Averincev S. (2003). Scholastica. In: Dictionary of medieval culture. Moscow, ROSPEN Publ. (In Russian).
  • Aristotle (1978-1984). Works in 4 volumes. Moscow, Thought [Mysl] Publ. (In Russian).
  • The Bible. Moscow, Russian Bible Society, 2011. (In Russian).
  • Block М. (2003). Feudal Society. Moscow, Publ. House Named after Sabashnikovs, vol. 2. (In Russian).
  • Braudel F. (1997). What Is France? People and Things. Moscow, Publ. House Named after Sabashnikovs, vol. 2.2. (In Russian).
  • Le Hoff J. (1992). Civilization of Medieval West. Moscow, Progress Publishing Group. Progress-Academy, vol. 2. (In Russian).
  • Le Hoff J. (2007). The Birth of Europe. St. Petersburg, Publ. House «Alexandria». (In Russian).
  • Le Hoff J. (2010). Middle Ages and Money. Sketch of Historical Anthropology. St. Petersburg, Eurasia Publ. (In Russian).
  • Duby G. (1976). Le Temps des cathedrales. L’art et la societe 980-1420 years. Galimard, Paris. (Russian edition, Moscow, 2002).
  • Gurevich А. Y. (1984). Categories of Medieval Culture. 2nd edition. Moscow, 1984. (In Russian).
  • Gurevich А. Y. (1990). Medieval world: Culture of Silent Majority. Moscow, Arts, vol. I. (In Russian).
  • History of Middle Ages. Vol. 1, 2 / Ed. by S. P. Karpov. Moscow, 2001. (In Russian).
  • Kulisher I. M. (1906). Evolution of capital gains in connection with the development of industry and trade in Western Europe. St. Petersburg. (In Russian).
  • Mike Yu. (1994). Social Doctrine of the Catholic Church Rome, Lublin. (In Russian).
  • Marx K. and Engels F. Works. 2nd edition. (In Russian).
  • Nureev R. M. (1989). Economic System of Pre-Capitalist Formation. (Dialectics of productive forces and production relations). Dushanbe. (In Russian).
  • Nureev R. M. (2005). Shumpeter Y. А.: Role of Scholasticism in the History of Economic Analysis. Economic Herald of Rostov State University, vol. 3, no. 4. (In Russian).
  • Robbins L. (2013). History of Economic Thought. Lections in London Scholl of Economy. Мoscow. (In Russian).
  • Skazkin S. D. (1973). Selected Works on History. Мoscow. (In Russian).
  • Dictionary of Medieval Culture. Ed. by A. Y. Gurevich. Мoscow, ROLSEN Publ., 2003. (In Russian).
  • Stetsura T. D. (2010). Economic Ethics of Thomas Aquinas. Мoscow. (In Russian).
  • Shumpeter Y. (1982). Theory of Economic Development (Study of Business Profits, Capital, Credits, Interest and Cycle Conditions). Мoscow, Progress Publ. (In Russian).
  • Shumpeter Y. (2001). History of Economic Analysis. In 3 vols. Vol. 1. St. Petersburg. (In Russian).
  • Trachtenberg O. (1957). Essays on the History of Western Medieval Philosophy. Мoscow. (In Russian).
  • Ashley U. G. (1897). Economic History of England in Connection with Economic Theory. Мoscow. (In Russian).
  • Abel W. (1962). Geschichte der deutschen Landwirtschaft von fruhen Mittelalter bis zum 19. Jahrhundert Stuttgart.
  • Baldwin L. W. (1959). The Medieval Theories od the Just Price. Romanists, Canonists and Theologians in the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centures // Transactions of the American Philosophical Society. Philadelphia, vol. 49.
  • Contzen H. (1869). Geschichte der volkswirtschaftlichen Literatur. Leipzig.
  • Fanfani A. (1935). Catholicism, Protestantism and Kapitalism. N. Y.
  • Greif A. (2001). Lessons from Medieval Trade«On the History of the Institutional Foundations of Impersonal Exchange: From Communal to Individual Responsibility in Pre-modern Europe». Stanford.
  • Greif A. (2006). Institutions and the Path to the Modern Economy. Cambridge University Press.
  • Hagenauer S. (1931). Das «justum pretium» bei Thomas von Aquin, Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der objektiven Werttheorie, Stuttgart.
  • Kraus J.-B. (1930). Scholastik, Puritanismus and Kapitalismus. Leipzig.
  • Munro J. (2000). «Wage-Stickiness, Monetary Changes, and Real Incomes in Late-Medieval England and the Low Countries, 1300-1450: Did Money Really Matter?». (http://repec.economics.utoronto.ca/files/UT-ECIPA-MUNRO-00-03.pdf).
  • Murray A. (1978). Reason and Society in the Middle Ages. Oxford University Press.
  • Noonan J. T. (1957). The Scholastic Analysis of Usury. Cambridge (Mass.).
  • De Roover R. (1958). The Concept of the Just Price: Theory and Economic Policy // The Journal of Economic History, vol. 18, no. 4.
  • Rost K., Inauen E., Osterloh M. and Frey B. (2008). The Corporate Governance of Benedictine Abbeys: What can Stock Corporations Learn from Monasteries? (http://www.iew.uzh.ch/wp/iewwp374.pdf).
  • Sapori A. (1955). Il giusto prezzo nella dottrina di San Tommaso e nella pratica del suo tempo // Sapori A. Studi di storia economica. Secoli XIII-XIV-XV. Firenze, vol. 1.
  • Scbilling O. (1923). Die Staats-und Soziallehre des hl. Thomas von Aquin. Paderborn.
  • Schreiber E. (1913). Die volkswirtschaftlichen Anschauungen der Scholastik seit Thomas von Aquin. Jena, 3, VIII, 246 I.
  • Tawney R. H. (1963). Religion and te Rise of Capitalism. (1 ed. – 1926).
  • Tomas Aquinas. (1901). Summa Theologica. Taurini, vol. 1-6.

 

Publisher: Ltd. "Humanitarian perspectives"
Founder: Ltd. "Humanitarian perspectives"
ISSN: 2076-6297