Pushkinskaya st. 43. office 10
Rostov-on-Don, Russia
e-mail: info@hjournal.ru 
tel. +7(863) 269-88-14

cubsEN (2)

Narrative Analysis of Institutional Traps of Education and Science in Russia

Narrative Analysis of Institutional Traps of Education and Science in Russia

Journal of Institutional Studies, , Vol. 11 (no. 1),

For last 30 years Russian science and education system has been experiencing constant, profound institutional transformation in order to increase the quality of education, it's access ability and with a point to encrease the effectiveness of science. This article is devoted to the attempt to analysis the results of undertaken reforms and evaluating the quality of economic institutions which coordinate the order of market agents of researching field. The analysis of narratives approach was chosen with the intention for estimating the quality of reforms undertaken. Narratives are defined to be stories in direct speech of actors themselves of researching field: professors, students, Master’s and graduated students of all forms of education, as soon as scientists and researchers of universities and research institutes and different levels of responsibility and competencies administrators. The "Integrum" database taken as the main source of information for searching for narratives. This informational base consists of 1250 Russian newspapers (federal and regional) and 500 journals which help us to select 250 narratives (stories in direct speech) of people who are directly involved in transformational process of education system and science being studied. The obtained results pointed out the number of stable ineffective rules and practices which have a negative impact on our researching area functioning and also made it possible to classify out a few groups of institutional traps such as: metric's trap, trap of raising level of bureacracy, trap of shortage of finansing, electronization and digitalization trap and trap of staff capacity. Each determined trap reflected in the article is also pointed out and argued with selected narratives.

Keywords: institution; institutional transformation; institutional trap; narrative; narrative analysis; science and higher education sphere

  • Akindinova, N., Aleksashenko, S., Petronevich, A. and Petronevich, M. (2011). How many non-performing institutions cost? Voprosy ekonomiky, 8, 41–65. (In Russian).
  • Alchian, A. A. (1977). Some economics of property rights, economic forces at work. Liberty Fund: Indianapolis, 127–149.
  • Arthur, W. B. (1989). Competing technologies, increasing returns, and lock-in by historical events. The economic journal, 99(394), 116–131.
  • Barsukova, S. Yu. and Korobkova, A. D. (2014). Russia’s Accession to the WTO in the Mirror of Russian Print Media. Journal of Economic Sociology, 15 (4), 20–44. (In Russian).
  • Belokrylova, O. and Zhuk, A., (2007). Institutionalization of the competitive environment of the post-crisis economy. Rostov-on-Don. (In Russian).
  • Bratishchev, I. M. (2016). Western colonization of Russian education: the consequences and the need for confrontation. Education. (https://www.politpros.com/journal/read/?ID=5566&journal=188). (In Russian).
  • Burtseva, I. (2013). Inefficient universities of Udmurtia will not close // Komsomolskaya Pravda. (https://www.izh.kp.ru/daily/26159.4/3046822/). (In Russian).
  • Chebotarev, P. (2016). “Right “scientists against” wrong “ // Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Bashkortostan. (http://www.anrb.ru/snews/alias/18910). (In Russian).
  • Chestakov, A. (2017). In the footsteps of Stolypin: reforming education at the leading University of the southern Urals // Dostup (https://dostup1.ru/society/Po-sledam-Stolypinareformirovanie-obrazovaniya-v-veduschem-universitete-Yuzhnogo-Urala_101705.html). (In Russian).
  • Clark, B. R. (1983). The Higher Education System: Academic Organization in Cross-National Perspective.
  • Crimskii, G. (2016). “Effective managers” do not understand how science works // Russian Academy of Sciences. (http://www.ras.ru/news/shownews.aspx?id=95a9a47b-96cd-47d5-82eb-dda67e0b758a). (In Russian).
  • David, P. A. (1985). Clio and the Economics of QWERTY. The American economic review, 75(2), 332–337.
  • Fedorenko, A. (2016). Meeting in defense of Russian science in Pushchino // Moscow regional branch of the Communist party. (http://mkkprf.ru/16463-miting-v-zaschiturossiyskoy-nauki-v-puschino.html).
  • Fuchs, D. and Fuchs, L. S. (1994). Counterpoint: Special Education – Ineffective? Immoral? Exceptional children, 61(3), 303–306.
  • Fursov, A. I. (2013). A new education for a new reality... // Роcсия.info. (https://www.docme.doc/69879/andrej-fursov---novoe-obrazovanie-dlya-novoj-real._nosti). (In Russian).
  • Grinko, V. (2013). Arrested the head of the Higher attestation Commission: opinions // News Agency. (http://www.iarex.ru/interviews/33806.html). (In Russian).
  • Hayek, F. (1992). Fatal presumptional. The mistakes of socialism. Moscow. (In Russian).
  • Hayek, F. (2014). The fatal conceit. University of Chicago Press. The constitution of liberty. Routledge. (In Russian).
  • Koroteev, A. (2017). Personnel arbitrariness – malignant tumor of Russia? // Economy and life-Chernozem. (http://www.eizh.ru/articles/analitika/kadrovyy-proizvolzlokachestvennaya-opukhol-rossii/). (In Russian).
  • Long, C. S., Kowang, T. O., Ismail, W. K. and Rasid, S. Z. (2013). A review on performance appraisal system: An ineffective and destructive practice. Middle East Journal of Scientific Research, 14(7), 887–891.
  • Lubomirova, I. (2018). The HSE’s suggestion that they replace professors of online courses will lead to the final collapse of the whole system of higher education // Ermak-info. (http://ермак-инфо.рф/2018/03) (In Russian).
  • Malkina, M. and Rozmainsky, I. (2001). Fundamentals of institutional approach to the analysis of the role of the state / Economic subjects of post-Soviet Russia. Ed. yes. R. M. Nureev. Moskow: MPSF, 571–577. (In Russian).
  • Menger, K. (1894). Investigations into the Method of the Social Sciences with Special Reference to Economics, Sanct-Petersburg: Tzezerling, с. 17. (In Russian).
  • Nechaev, A. F. (2013). On reforms, quality of education and innovation economy // Civic stand. (http://netreforme.org/news/o-reformah-kachestve-obrazovaniya-I-innovatsionnoyekonomike/). (In Russian).
  • North, D. (1997). Institutional changes: frameworks of analysis. Voprosy ekonomiki, 3, 6–17. (In Russian).
  • North, D. (1997). Institutions, Institutional change and economic performance, Moskow, Nachala, 17–21. (In Russian).
  • Oleynik, A. (1997). The Costs and Prospects of Economic Reforms in Russia – An Institutional Approach. Moskow: Magistr. (In Russian).
  • Polonsky, I. (2015). The destruction of universities continues // Newspaper «Tomorrow». (http://trueinform.ru/modules.php?name=News&sid=39709). (In Russian).
  • Polterovich, V. (1999). Institutional traps and economic reforms. Ekonomika I matematicheskie metody, 35(2), 3–20. (In Russian).
  • Polterovich, V. (2001). Transplantation of economic institutions. Ekonomicheskaya nauka sovremennoi Rossii, 3. (In Russian).Researchers have proven the effectiveness of online education. (2018) // Rambler. (https://news.rambler.ru/education/39369932-issledovateli-dokazali-effektivnost-onlaynobrazovaniya/). (In Russian).
  • Resolution of the meeting of staff of the RAS Research center institutes in Chernogolovka. (2016). // Russian Academy of Sciences. (http://www.ras.ru/news/shownews.aspx?id=ae306a9fddeb-4ef9-8941-0c2a669a4abe). (In Russian).
  • Reynolds, D. (1995). The Ineffective School.
  • Sadovsky, M. (2016). The reform of the RAS: the time of political correctness is over, it’s time to call a spade a spade // Sulakshina Center. (http://rusrand.ru/analytics/reformaran-vremya-politkorrektnosti-zakonchilos-davno-pora-nazvat-veschi-svoimi-imenami). (In Russian).
  • Sakharova, E. (2018). “The era of domination of full-time education is over” // RT in Russian. (https://russian.rt.com/russia/article/492300-obrazovanie-issledovanieuniversitet). (In Russian).
  • Smirnova, A. (2018). Overgrown fields, cold audience and leaky ceilings through which to fly pigeons in the city Duma discussed the situation in Timiryazevka // The day Before. (https://www.nakanune.ru/news/2018/02/2/22499331/). (In Russian).
  • The Union leader. (2015). Insane policy of the Ministry of education leads to a decrease in the quality of higher education // Innovative education network Eureka. (http://www.rosbalt.ru/russia/2015/09/01/1435770.html). (In Russian).
  • Veblen, T. (2017). The theory of the leisure class. Routledge.
  • Vedeneeva, N. (2016). The actions of FANOs cause a shock: they want to unite the chemical institute with a polyclinic // Russian Academy of Sciences. (http://www.ras.ru/digest/showdnews.aspx?id=2ee2f25f-f0ed-4887-8cdf-f8194f4bf226). (In Russian).
  • Volchik, V. V. (2017). Narrative and Institutional Economics. Journal of Institutional Studies, 9(4), 134. (In Russian).
  • Volchik, V. V. and Maslyukova, E. V. (2018). Narratives, ideas and institutions. Terra Economicus, 16(2), 150–168.
  • Volchik, V. V. and Maslyukova, E. V. (2018). The metrics trap, or why is implicit knowledge underestimated when regulation of science and education is handled. Journal of institutional studies, 10(3), 158–179.
  • Volchik, V., Korytsev, M. and Maslyukova, E. (2018). Institutional Traps and New Public Management in the Sphere of Education and Science. The Manager, 9(6), 23.
  • Volchik, V., Zhuk, A. and Korytcev, M. (2017). Competitive environment of higher education market of Rostov region. Terra Economicus, 15(3), 184–186. (In Russian).
  • Voltskaia, T. (2017). Simplification, reduction // Radio liberty. (https://www.svoboda.org/a/28904306.html). (In Russian).
  • Zhuk, A. А. (2010). Structural and dynamic aspects of instability of economic institutions. Perspektivy nauki, 3, 120–126. (In Russian).
  • Zhuk, A. A. (2018). Institutional traps in the sphere of higher education. Actual Problems of Economics and Law, 4, 48. (In Russian).
Publisher: Ltd. "Humanitarian perspectives"
Founder: Ltd. "Humanitarian perspectives"
Online-ISSN: 2412-6039
ISSN: 2076-6297